Comments on: Young Justice Primer

By: alcinde4

alcinde4 — Fri, 24 Dec 2010 16:04:05 +0000

I think once everyone that views the show grasps the fact that this is a COMPLETELY different DCU, the show becomes infinitely more enjoyable. I didn’t have any problems disassociating these incarnations of the characters on the show, from the ones I grew up reading/watching. I’m kind of confused why others are having this difficulty. I think this show is fantastic, and I hope it lasts many, many seasons.

By: Brainlock

Brainlock — Fri, 24 Dec 2010 13:46:03 +0000

I finally got to watch the pilot, and I see no reason why they couldn’t have included this in the 20 years of BTAS/JLU continuity or even 5 year long The Batman continuity.
(B&B has already established itself as separate from both, early on.)
.
A few minor tweaks to characters like making them Tim and Bart esp when “Barry” is wearing WALLY’s suit, J’onn is wearing his pre-death/Co2E look, and Arthur is sporting a beard, not to mention including more recent additions like Conner (in t-shirt), Megan, and Jackson(?/Aqualad II), who already has more development as a cartoon than he has in Brightest Day.
.
The only standout would be having Roy on the series, esp after the Titans appearances and JLU cameo. With having established his brash personality, we can’t fall back to making him Conner Hawk without totally changing the character. But hey, when Robin and Kid Flash don’t even act like Dick and Wally, but Tim/Damian and Bart, who cares, right?
.
I do like the fact they’re going to push the fact this show has BOTH teams by frequently including the JL, when TT could only make a few veiled references to Robin’s “father” at the time. Bonus points for Mattel planning the mentor/sidekick sets.
.
I’m going to give it a chance, but in my mind, it will be THE Young Justice members under those masks, NOT the TITANS they insist on calling them.

By: Bat Lantern

Bat Lantern — Mon, 20 Dec 2010 17:37:47 +0000

I liked the pilot. I can’t think of DC animated show that hasn’t had to bend comic continuity to work.. With 50-75 years of complex and contradictory story lines, I would say this is a great cast. I am hoping for a Hal Jordan cameo.

By: superfriend

superfriend — Sun, 19 Dec 2010 18:49:23 +0000

That is kind of cool. I had no idea. Thanks for bringing this to my attention. I’d still like to see Donna featured.

By: stonehd

stonehd — Wed, 15 Dec 2010 17:06:11 +0000

Regarding Teen Titans Go, Wonder Girl did make two “blink-and-you-miss-em” cameos, both on viewscreens near the end of the series (see http://www.titanstower.com/source/animated/charwondergirl.html ). She was featured a bit more in the TTG comics ( see http://comicbjooks.blogspot.com/search/label/Wonder%20Girl for some images.)

By: superfriend

superfriend — Sat, 11 Dec 2010 23:45:23 +0000

Good Points. At the same time, we had to throw out DCU comic history for Justice League, Justice League Unlimited, and Teen Titans Go.
JL – Aquaman not a founding member. They forgot to offer Metamorpho membership. Green Arrow should have joined the team within their first year.
JLU – Some of these characters never existed on the same Earth or at the same time. Shining Knight, Question, and Stargirl certainly were never members of any incarnation of the comic Justice League.
TTG – Starfire’s successful arrival on Earth depends on Kid Flash, who did not appear until much later in the series, and Wonder Girl, who was never on the show. Titans Tower is on the wrong side of the United States.
Then again, DC Comics themselves revises history every so often. From Crisis on Infinite Earths merging separate Earths to Man of Steel revising Lex Luthor from a scientist to a corporate industrialist. More recently, Maxwell Lord was changed from an opportunist with a flair for publicity into someone trying to destroy the entire super-powered community.

By: red Ricky

red Ricky — Sat, 11 Dec 2010 19:51:53 +0000

Basically, that’s the weird thing about the show. It’s a good show, don’t get me wrong; the pilot was a blast. But I know so much about the DC Universe and its continuity, that I have to PURPOSELY remember to turn my brain off before watching, and while watching! It’s just weird watching a “johnny come lately” team all of a sudden “precede” the Titans.

Plus, their personalities can also throw me for a loop. When I used to watch the Teen Titans, they made a point of not having a big secret identity reveal. Robin was Robin. Speedy was Speedy, and Kid Flash was Kid Flash. But their personalities and character voices were unequivocally those of Dick Grayson, Roy Harper and Wally West.

With Young Justice, I had to remind myself that I was watching Wally West even though the character walked, talked and acted like Impulse. Robin was off, too. He reminded me more of Damian.

So it’s weird, because at times, it all takes me “out of the story”.

I had the same problem with the New Batman Adventures(TNBA). The character was called “Tim Drake”, but for all itends and purposes, I felt like I was watching JASON TODD. Their origins were “too similar”, their tragic nature and how it all ended was “too similar”.

Honestly, it was all too distracting.

I often wondered “why not just call him Jason Todd?”, and be done with it. It’s just a name, what’s the big deal?

By: superfriend

superfriend — Sat, 11 Dec 2010 14:33:44 +0000

Yes, they said their were a handful they could not use but had been cleared. I don’t remember Wonder Girl specifically being mentioned. As for Garth, he will be appearing and is Aqualad’s best friend.

By: superfriend

superfriend — Sat, 11 Dec 2010 14:31:56 +0000

According to the writers at NYCC, everything is based around wanting this to be an early DC universe. Near the beginning. So they are going with the first Robin, the first Kid Flash.

By: zach

zach — Sat, 11 Dec 2010 14:04:11 +0000

I missed the premier of this show, and can’t wait for it to start in January. I am a bit confused though…so, Robin is Dick and Kid Flash is Wally? With Conner? Why not just use Tim and Bart?

By: erik

erik — Sat, 11 Dec 2010 03:51:41 +0000

right before the show aired, the producers said ALOT of characters they didn’t have the rights for were given to them (especially Wonder Girl), and that she would eventually show up.

they’ve also said that Garth will show up.

By: superfriend

superfriend — Fri, 10 Dec 2010 22:55:32 +0000

While Artemis may not be Arrowette, the creators said she was an existing DCU character. I am firmly convinced that she is in fact a member of the Arrow family, Mia Derden, the current Speedy. In a way, that kind of fits with the pickign and choosing of teens from various eras.

By: Darrell

Darrell — Fri, 10 Dec 2010 22:46:45 +0000

IT’s probably the same reason that there is a whole slew of people out there enraged at the fact that Ryan Reynolds is playing Green Lantern and not some African-American actor – people don’t know about the source material. For a lot of people out there, John Stewart is Green Lantern because he helped headline the Justice League cartoon. Those people never even heard of Hal Jordan, the original SILVER AGE Green Lantern. Which is laughable to me, but hey, let’s hate without getting our facts straight. That’s par for the course on the ol’ internet.
Sometimes continuity is a problem for me, and sometimes, like in a cartoon univers, it’s not. Would I have liked to see Arrowette instead of this Artemis character they are touting? Sure. Would I have liked to see Garth Aqualad instead of the new Aqualad? Hmmm, no, I don’t think so. I think the new character has some serious “sea legs” in under him.
To wrap up this long and winding post, I am already in serious love with this cartoon, and I can’t wait to see more! Hopefully much, much more!

By: Shellhead

Shellhead — Fri, 10 Dec 2010 22:26:06 +0000

I agree. I just don’t get why some fanboys have their undies in a bunch over this show. Yes, it would have been awesome to have a continuation of JLU. And yes, it would have been great to have the original characters/new characters playing the same roles as they did in the comic (I would have liked the original Aqualad/Tempest to be in it, but I have to admit the new guy seems pretty compelling thus far). I do wonder why Cassie or Donna can’t make an appearance, though.
It’s Earth-16. Old continuality does not apply.
All I know is if the rest of the series is as good as the sneak peak was, I finally have a DC show I can consider a worthy successor to JLU.