updated the list...

Giffen's JLI

Martian Manhunter (Classic)
Green Lantern Guy Gardner
Fire (Adam Hughes costume)
Ice (Adam Hughes costume)
Rocket Red (Apokolips armor) CnC
Dr. Light (Kimiyo Hoshi classic)
Huntress (Classic)
Doctor Fate (Linda Strauss)
General Glory
Animal Man
Flash Wally West
Elongated Man (JLE costume)
Crimson Fox
Blue Jay
Silver Sorceress
L-Ron

Super Friends

Apache Chief
Black Vulcan
Samurai
El Dorado

Oracle
Zatanna
Huntress
Spoiler as Robin
Batwoman (modern)
Commissioner Gordon
Poison Ivy
Talia
King Snake
Mad Hatter
Raven

Maxima

Arsenal (Outsiders)

Tempest (Garth)

Donna Troy (Darkstars)

Flash (Wally West)

Extant

Comet (Modern)

Icon

Mr. Majestic

Valor

Infinity-Man

Ion (Sodam Yat)

Killer Frost (Crystal Frost )

Dr. Polaris (Neal Emerson)

Dr. Light (Arthur Light)

Zoom (Hunter Zolomon)

Monarch (Nathaniel Adam)

Parallax (Hal Jordan)

Superboy-Prime

Celsius

In no order EXCEPT the first two spots:

MARTIAN MANHUNTER- classic/BA
ROBIN - Dick Grayson (adult/NTT)
Beast Boy - NTT/BA
Kid Flash - NTT/BA (that shrimp we got works for SA not BA)
Raven - NTT/BA
Speedy - BA
Aqualad - BA
Wondergirl - NTT/BA
Black Lightning - classic/BA
Blue Devil - classic/BA
Cheetah - classic
Riddler - classic
Catwoman - classic
Tomar Re - classic GL uniform
Zatanna - satellite era/Perez costume
Elongated man - satellite era/ black-red
E2 Robin - yellow/orange/green
E2 Huntress
GA Green Lantern / Alan Scott
GA Flash / Jay Garrick

Twenty most wanted for DCUC:

Black Canary (JLI 80's Version)
Zatanna Zatara (Satellite/Detroit League Perez outfit)
Aquagirl (Tula)
Hawk(Hank Hall)
Dove(Dawn Granger)
Martian Manhunter
Elongated Man
Vixen(80's version)
Fire
Ice
Guy Gardner
Dr. Light Kimiyo Hoshi
Mera
Obsidian
Supergirl (Crisis on Infinite Earths version)
Shadow Thief
Count Vertigo
Cheetah
Wonder Girl Donna Troy
Lori Lemaris

Lots of girls on my list- but they all deserve a shot to be in the series.

Val

How about
the atom
amazo
black lightning
eradicator
the riddler
metallo c&c

I could go buy about 20 Riddlers right now haha so let's skip that one.

Here's my updated version:

Martian Manhunter
New Supergirl (w/o "something about Mary" hair_
John Stewart
Superman (as close to Chris Reeve as you can!)

Steppenwolf
Desaad
Tyr
Mr. Freeze (BTAS version)
Dr. Destiny
Doomsday CnC
Lex Luthor Business Suit or LoD jumpsuit

JLoA: Zatanna in Perez Satellite era costume

JLI: Rocket Red #4

JLA: Zauriel (Golden Eagle Armor)
JLA/BOP: Huntress in Jim Lee version of costume

JLoA II: Vixen

LoD: Toyman

TTitans: Raven

1. Martian Manhunter
2. Zatanna (Perez costume)
3. Elongated Man (red/black, C&C)
4. Golden Age Dr. Mid-Nite
5. Golden Age Green Lantern Alan Scott
6. Golden Age Flash Jay Garrick
7. Huntress (Earth-2)
8. Golden Age Hawkman
9. Golden Age Atom
10. Star Spangled Kid
11. Golden Age Superman
12. Golden Age Wonder Woman
13. Golden Age Hourman
14. Robin (Earth-2, red/yellow costume)
15. Jonny Thunder and Thunder bolt
16. Starfile (NTT)
17. Wonder Girl (Donna Troy)
18. Changeling (NTT)
19. Raven (classic)
20. Robin (Dick Grayson)

Martian Manhunter
Dick Grayson Robin
Kyle Rayner GL
Guy Gardner GL
GA Green Lantern Alan Scott
GA Flash Jay Garrick
Jack Knight Starman
The Shade
Hourman
Psycho Pirate
Earth 2 Huntress
GA Ted Knight Starman
Speedy (Roy Harper)
Red Robin
Wally West Flash
Phantom Lady
Stargirl
S.T.R.I.P.E.
Johnny Quick (Johnny Chambers, not evil version)
(and my personal "Killer Moth"...) The Red Bee

where?

I prefer Silver and Golden Age versions of characters as you can see from the list below. I left out Beast Boy and Robotman because they have been announced in an upcoming wave. I hope they are the classic Silver Age versions.

1. Chief (Doom Patrol- Silver Age)
2. Elasti-Girl (Silver Age)
3. Larry Trainor w/Negative Man pack in (Silver Age)
4. Mento (Silver Age)
5. Batman (Golden Age/Earth 2)
6. Robin (Golden Age, young)
7. Felix Faust (Silver Age)
8. Ultra Humanite (White Ape)
9. Chronos (Silver Age)
10. Catman (Silver Age)
11. Creeper (Silver Age/Bronze Age)
12. Johnny Thunder & Thunderbolt (Golden Age/Earth 2)
13. Mr. Terrific (Golden Age/Earth 2)
14. Captain Boomerang (Silver Age)
15. Trickster (Silver Age)
16. Heatwave (Silver Age)
17. Arisia
18. General Immortus
19. Jor-El (Silver Age)
20. Lara (Silver Age)

Jack Knight Starman
Ted Knight Starman
Mikaal Tomas Starman
Prince Gavyn Starman
Will Payton Starman (red and black)
Thom Kallor Starman
Bronze Tiger
Black Orchid
Aztek
Zauriel
Enchantress (witch hat)
Hitman (Tommy Monaghan)
Black Orchid
Sand
Sandman (Wesley Dodds)
The Shade
The Mist (Nash)
The Mist (GA)
Shade the Changing Man