You knew it was coming...



With the news of the DCUC Infinite Earths Club moving forward yet again for 2013, let's help the Mattel crew plan out the Club Infinite Earths for the rest of Year 2 in 2013 (which is likely already planned), and heading towards 2014. As the A-listers will still be at retail, along with the more visible B-Listers, keep the SuperWonderGreenBat guys out - the club is for the fan-favorites and true "classics".

Yes, it's silly, and dumb, and it's just for fun. I'm not looking for the always-helpful "how do we know it will even last until 2014?" or "another stupid wishlist thread?? boring!!" comments - just give me your Top 12 monthly characters plus 4 quarterly oversized figures. AND don't forget about the Sub Exclusive - let's give Mattel and 4H some really creative ideas for an awesome exclusive!

Announced for Club Infinite Earths 2012 (beginning in April)
Jay Garrick Flash
Red Lantern Atrocitus
Starman (modern, w/ extra Thom Kallor head)
Rocket Red (Oversize)
Mirror Master
Black Mask
Poison Ivy
Elasti-Girl (Oversize)
John Constantine
Uncle Sam & Doll Man
Platinum & Tin
Lead
Metron w/ Mobius Chair (Club Figure)

Announced for Club Infinite Earths 2013
Blue Lantern Saint Walker
Phantom Stranger
Elongated Man
Agent Orange Larfleeze
Flash Wally West
Monsieur Mallah & the Brain (Club figure)


I will keep a running tally of votes in the next post.

1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8 )
9)
10)
11)
12)

Oversize 1)
Oversize 2)
Oversize 3)
Oversize 4)

Sub Exclusive

Mattel's definition of A,B,C-Listers: (although this is from 2008, and may be obsolete)
All of the main heroes of the JLU are pretty much "A" list characters as far as our unofficial internal character selection process. "B" list characters are more like Dr. Fate, Mr. Terrific, Black Canary. "C" list character would be people like Steel, Orion, Deadshot, and fan favorites would be characters like Etrigan, Kamandi, Blue Devil, etc. Honestly, there is no set rule, but as far as the "A" list anchor characters, we look at Superman, Wonder Woman, Batman, Green Arrow, Green Lantern(s), Shazam, Flash, Hawkman, Aquaman and Martian Manhunter as good core characters to anchor a line.


Archive 'Wish List' reference threads:

viewtopic.php?f=5&t=16937

viewtopic.php?t=14339

viewtopic.php?t=9997

TOP VOTES (updated 01.04.12)
(some characters may be listed in Oversize/Exclusive sections)

Heroes

11 Zauriel
10 Huntress (modern)

9 Fire
9 Ice
9 Mera (classic)
9 Vixen
9 Zatanna (Perez Costume)

8 Dawnstar

7 Captain Marvel Jr.
7 Liberty Belle

6 Hourman (Rick Tyler)
6 Phantom Stranger

5 Aztek
5 Jade
5 Lady Blackhawk
5 Static Shock

4 Aqualad (classic Garth)
4 Aquaman (hook/beard)
4 Black Lightning (classic)
4 Blue Lantern Saint Walker
4 Doctor Mid-Nite (Pieter Cross)
4 Flash (Wally West)
4 Katana (classic)
4 Miss Martian
4 Mister Terrific (Terry Sloane)
4 Oracle (w/ wheelchair & computer)
4 Platinum
4 Uncle Sam
4 Vigilante (classic)
4 Wonder Girl (Cassie Sandsmark)

3 Blackhawk
3 Changeling (red/white costume)
3 Crimson Avenger (suit/fedora)
3 Cyclone (Maxine Hunkel) w/ monkey
3 Damage (modern)
3 Detective Chimp
3 Enchantress
3 Geo-Force
3 Green Arrow (Connor Hawke)
3 Green Lantern Kyle Rayner (original costume)
3 Highfather
3 Huntress (Earth-2, Helena Wayne)
3 Jericho
3 John Constantine
3 Mento
3 Phantom Girl
3 Red Tornado (Ma Hunkle)
3 Sand (Sandy Hawkins, JSA costume)
3 Tempest (Garth)

2 Big Barda (larger redo)
2 Bloodwynd
2 Blue Beetle (Dan Garrett)
2 Captain Carrot
2 Captain Comet (classic)
2 The Chief (Dr. Niles Caulder)
2 Death (Vertigo)
2 Flamebird (Bette Kane)
2 Gypsy
2 Hawkman (modern)
2 Hourman (Matthew Tyler android)
2 Jesse Quick
2 Manhunter (Paul Kirk)
2 Nightshade
2 Nightmaster
2 Nightwing (classic 80s)
2 Secret
2 Shadow Lass
2 Speedy (classic Roy Harper)
2 Speedy (Mia Dearden)
2 Star Spangled Kid (Sylvester Pemberton)
2 Tin
2 Tomcat/Wildcat III

1 Amanda Waller
1 Amazing Man
1 Ambush Bug
1 Argent
1 Batgirl (Stephanie Brown)
1 Batwoman (modern Kate Kane)
1 Batman (DC 1Million)
1 Black Orchid (classic)
1 Brother Power the Geek
1 Blue Devil (modern)
1 Bouncing Boy
1 Checkmate
1 Donna Troy (modern)
1 Element Lad
1 Ferro Lad
1 The Flaming C
1 Flash (John Fox)
1 Green Lantern Alan Scott (Kingdom Come armor)
1 Green Lantern Arisia
1 Green Lantern Galius Zed
1 Green Lantern Salaak
1 Guardians of Oa (3-pack)
1 Halo (classic)
1 Harbinger
1 Hawk (Holly Granger)
1 Hawkgirl (Golden Age)
1 Huntress (90s)
1 Hippolyta
1 I...Vampire (classic Andrew Bennett)
1 Icon
1 Impulse (Bart Allen)
1 Isis
1 Johnny Quick
1 Judomaster (Sonia Sato)
1 Klarion the Witch-Boy w/ Teekl
1 Kryptonian Fortress Droids (3-pack)
1 Lightning (Jennifer Pierce)
1 Manhunter (Kate Spencer)
1 Mister Bones (business suit w/ cigar)
1 Mon-El
1 Pariah
1 Phantom Lady I (Sandra Knight)
1 Phantom Lady III (Stormy Knight)
1 Polar Boy
1 Ragman
1 Ravager (Rose Wilson)
1 1 Raven (white costume)
1 The Ray
1 Red Robin announced for DC All-Stars
1 Red Star
1 Robin (Earth-2, red/yellow)
1 Robin (Tim Drake, classic redo)
1 Sandman (Sandy Hawkins, modern)
1 Sgt. Rock
1 Spoiler
1 Starfire (redo)
1 Sun Boy
1 Supergirl (Matrix)
1 Takion
1 Terra
1 Traci 13
1 The Unknown Soldier
1 Valda, the Iron Maiden
1 Vibe
1 Warlord
1 Will Magnus
1 Wonder Woman (Kingdom Come armor)
1 Zatara


Villains

11 Granny Goodness
11 Trickster (classic James Jesse)

8 Mirror Master

7 Heat Wave
7 Ragdoll
7 Weather Wizard

6 Orange Lantern Larfleeze (announced for DC All-Stars)
6 Prometheus

5 Brother Blood (classic)
5 Doctor Light
5 Ocean Master
5 Ra's al Ghul

4 Atomic Skull
4 Count Vertigo
4 Doctor Polaris (modern)
4 Psycho Pirate
4 Vandal Savage

3 Chronos (classic)
3 Lashina
3 Pied Piper (modern)
3 Royal Flush Gang (Ace, Jack, King, Queen, Ten)
3 The Shade
3 The Top

2 Black Mask
2 Catwoman (Silver Age dress) (announced for Batman Legacy)
2 Catwoman (Balent costume)
2 Cheshire
2 Circe
2 Doctor Alchemy (modern)
2 Jeanette (w/ Banshee Head)
2 Jewelee
2 Johnny Sorrow
2 Knockout
2 Mad Hatter
2 Mister Mxyzptlk
2 Mr. Zsasz
2 Pied Piper (classic)
2 Punch
2 Scandal Savage
2 Signalman
2 Silver Swan
2 Talia

1 Anarky (w/ removable head extension)
1 Blackfire (classic)
1 Blight
1 Blockbuster
1 Bob the Goon
1 Brainiac (modern)
1 Catwoman (Batman Returns)
1 Clock King (classic)
1 Clayface III (Preston Payne, 80s costume)
1 Cluemaster (classic)
1 Crazy Quilt
1 Doctor Sivana
1 Emerald Empress
1 Evil Star (modern)
1 Felix Faust
1 Firefly
1 Fisherman
1 Floronic Man
1 General Zod (movie version)
1 Goldface (classic)
1 Kalibak (Super Powers)
1 Kanto
1 Killer Frost
1 Lady Shiva
1 Lex Luthor (business suit)
1 Lex Luthor (Byrne revamp, metallic hand)
1 Lex Luthor (Super Powers battle suit)
1 Livewire
1 Mad Harriet
1 Major Disaster (classic)
1 Mordru (classic)
1 Master Jailer
1 Maxima (classic)
1 Maxwell Lord
1 Metallo (modern)
1 Metallo (humanoid)
1 Morgaine Le Fey
1 Plastique
1 Queen Bee (classic)
1 Queen Bee (modern)
1 Qwardian Thunderer
1 Ravager
1 Red Hood (Joker)
1 Roulette
1 Shriek (Batman Beyond)
1 Slipknot
1 Stompa
1 The Tattooed Man (classic)
1 The Ten-Eyed Man
1 Toyman (Timmverse)
1 Ventriloquist and Scarface (Arnold Wesker)
1 Vermin Vunderbarr
1 Wotan (classic)

Oversize

16 Rocket Red
11 Doomsday

10 Elasti-Girl
10 King Shark

9 Elongated Man (classic, w/ attachments)
9 Shining Knight w/ Winged Victory
9 Starro

7 Johnny Thunder & Thunderbolt

6 Wildebeast

5 Blok (80s costume)

4 Blue Lantern Warth
4 Mister Atom (classic)

3 Blockbuster (classic)
3 The General
3 Lead
3 Wizard Shazam w/ chair on Rock of Eternity

2 Big Bear
2 Giganta (modern) w/ mini Atom (Ryan Choi)
2 Gog
2 Jakeem Thunder & Thunderbolt
2 Mammoth
2 Monsieur Mallah & Brain
2 Shaggy Man
2 Tellus

1 Alloy
1 Anton Arcane (demon insectoid)
1 Asmodel
1 Big Sir
1 Chemo (original "humanoid" version)
1 Frankenstein
1 Huntress w/ motorcycle
1 Kryptonian Battle Suit
1 Legion (GL Emerald Dawn)
1 Legion of Super Pets set ( Beppo, Comet, Krypto, Proty II, Streaky)
1 Lord Satanus
1 Mighty Endowed
1 Multiplex (classic) w/ multiple Mini-Duplicates
1 Neron
1 Pig-Iron
1 Queen of Fables
1 Solaris
1 Stanley Dover and Spot
1 Steel (Natasha Irons)
1 Tasmanian Devil
1 Triplicate Girl w/ Bouncing Boy


Subscription Exclusive

4 Batmobile w/ Alfred

2 Commissioner Gordon w/ working Batsignal
2 Elongated Man & Sue Dibney 2-pack
2 Royal Flush Gang 5-pack

1 Enemy Ace w/ Fokker Dr.1
1 Haunted Tank
1 JLA/JSA (reversible) Roundtable w/ chairs
1 Zebra Batman

Here's mine...

1) Zatanna (Perez Costume)
2) Uncle Sam (w/ Doll Man)
3) Elongated Man (w/ attachments)
4) Trickster (classic)
5) Chronos (classic)
6) GL Kyle Rayner (original costume)
7) Zauriel
8 ) Phantom Stranger
9) Silver Age Catwoman
10) Vigilante (classic)
11) Liberty Belle
12) Dawnstar (w/ Shrinking Violet)

Oversize 1) Starro
Oversize 2) Granny Goodness
Oversize 3) Rocket Red (w/ extra Dimitri head)
Oversize 4) Asmodel

Although I didnt subscribe-- if this list comes out Im in for sure .. not neccessarily release order

1) Spoiler
2) Lady Blackhawk
3) Speedy (MIA)
4) Miss Martian
5) Ravager
6) Wonder Girl (Cassie)
7) Ragdoll
8- Mad Hatter
9) Cheshire
10) Knockout
11) Janette (w/ Banshee Head)
12) CAPTAIN CARROT

Oversize

1) PIG- IRON
2)ORACLE (w/ Wheelchair)
3) King Shark (Secret Six)
4) Mighty Endowed

Just as a suggestion, you might include a list of who you think the likely candidates will be for THIS year's. That way people can narrow their focus a bit. I didn't include Huntress, since I figure we'll see her this year.

1) Larfleeze
2) Zatanna (Perez)
3) Liberty Belle
4) Uncle Sam
5) Phantom Belle
6) Dawnstar
7) Static Shock
Jade
9) Golden Age Hawkgirl
10) Damage
11) Johnny Quick
12) Black Mask

Club Exclusive:
Captain Carrot

Oversize 1) Starro
Oversize 2) Brother Warth
Oversize 3) Rocket Red (don't think they'll get to him this year)
Oversize 4) Killer Croc (WITH BABY DOLL!!!!! )

1) The Ray
2) Jericho
3) Damage
4) Red Star
5) Bloodwynd
6) Maxima
7) Zatanna (Perez)
8 ) Trickster (modern James Jesse)
9) Pied Piper (modern)
10) Brother Blood (classic)
11) Blackfire (classic)
12) Cheshire (classic)

Club Exclusive: Granny Goodness

Oversize 1) Wildebeest
Oversize 2) Mammoth
Oversize 3) Monsieur Mallah & Brain
Oversize 4) Rocket Red

Boots

1) Lead
2) Platinum
3) Tin
4) Doctor Magnus
5) Elasti-Girl
6) The Chief (of Doom Patrol)
7) Vigilante (classic)
Huntress
9) Robin (Earth II - red, green, yellow)
10) Lashina
11) Mad Harriet
12) Stompa

Club Exclusive: Granny Goodness

Oversize 1) Doomsday
Oversize 2) King Shark
Oversize 3) Shining Knight with Pegasus
OVersize 4) Johnny Thunder / Thunderbolt 2-pack

Good suggestion, I'm just not sure of who the likely candidates are. We have a pretty good idea that 2012 will see the rest of the rumored wave 21, plus the 4H and Mattel keep referencing 'completing teams' when asked about the Metal Men and Doom Patrol.

Here are all the names from the various 'rumor' lists:

Mento
Lead
Manhunter (Paul Kirk)
Metallo (Bronze Age)
Bizarro (Silver Age)
Golden Superman (could be Golden Age, or Super Powers Gold Supes)
Vandal Savage
The Shade
Black Lantern Firestorm
Arisia
Guardian
Saint Walker
Larfleeze

Elasti-Girl C&C
Starro C&C
Shaggy Man C&C

Dawnstar, Blackhawk, and Captain Marvel, Jr. were on some lists, too.

1 Granny Goodness
2 Kanto
3 Katana [original design, Aparo]
4 Dawnstar
5 Phantom Girl
6 Shadow Lass
7 Talia
8 Frankenstein
9 Zatanna [Perez/Satellite]
10 Phantom Stranger
11 Mera
12 Detective Chimp


1 Blok [Lightle/80's Who's Who]
2 Oracle w/ wheelchair
3 Big Bear
4 Tellus

Ryan, you forgot about the sub exclusive... Anyway, here's my crazy list...

1- Shining Knight
2- Anarky (w/ removable head extension)
3- Galius Zed
4- Crimson Avenger (cape and fedora costume)
5- Circe
6- Blue Beetle (Dan Garrett)
7- Death
8- Klarion the Witch-Boy w/ Teekl (re-use of modern Cheetah parts)
9- Red Tornado (Ma Hunkle)
10- Mr. Bones (business suit w/ cigar)
11- Giovanni Zatarra
12- Secret (transparent w/ slight over-spray and flying stand)

Oversize 1- Winged Vicotry (has to ship the same month as Sir Justin)
Oversize 2- Giganta (modern version) w/ mini Atom (Ryan Choi)
Oversize 3- Starro
Oversize 4- Stanley Dover and Spot

Oversize Club Exclusive- Elongated Man and Sue Dibney 2-pack

1- Zatanna(Perez Costume)
2- Captain Marvel Jr.
3- Aztek
4- Prometheus
5- Vixen
6- Elongatedman(w/ attachments/classic costume)
7- Phantom Stranger
8- Mera(Silver Age costume)
9- Isis
10- Sivana
11- Star-Spangled Kid(Sylvester)
12- Aqualad(Garth)

Oversize 1- Johnny Thunder & Thunderbolt
Oversize 2- Wizard Shazam with chair on Rock of Eternity base(I stole the idea from TRDouble cuz I like it)
Oversize 3- Mr. Atom
Oversize 4- Starro

Oversize Club Exclusive- Shining Knight & Winged Victory

and there are a few others I'd like to see also.

1. Jesse Quick
2. Vixen
3. Donna Troy
4. Wonder Girl (Cassie Sandsmark)
5. Tempest (Garth)
6. Ms. Martian
7. Hourman (Rick Tyler)
8. Huntress (Helena Wayne)
9. Ravager (Rose Wilson)
10. Mento
11. Talia
12. Platinum

Oversized
1.Rocket Red
2. Starro
3.Doomsday
4. Elasti-Girl

1) Aquaman (hook and beard)
2) Zauriel
3) Aztek
4) Prometheus
5) Mr. Zsasz
6) Sand
7) Dr. Mid-Nite (Pieter Cross)
8) Hourman (Rick Tyler)
9) Icon
10) Static
11) Dr. Light (Arthur Light)
12) Dr. Polaris (modern)

Oversize 1) The General
Oversize 2) Killer Croc
Oversize 3) King Shark
Oversize 4) Doomsday

1. Morgaine Le Fey
2. Brother Blood
3. Warlord
4. Atomic Skull
5. Trickster
6. Checkmate
7. Highfather
8. Uncle Sam
9. Any Royal Flush Gang member
Oversize
1. Doomsday
2. Wildebeast
3. Tasmanian Devil
Exclusive
Shining Knight w/ Winged Victory

I'm still thinking of my list, but one thing I will say is for all you guys putting Killer Croc down as being oversized, please re-think that. If we consider him oversized then mattel will make him as big as Lobo, and he really should only be the size of Etrigan.