Oh, this is tough! There are so many great characters left to be made. And I am trying to think of the over-sized figure more in terms of Metron than Rocket Red.

1)Classic Black Lightning
2)E2 Huntress
3)GA Star Spangled Kid
4)GA Mr. Terrific
5)Balent Catwoman
6)Zauriel
7)Conner Hawke
8 )SA Mera
9)Captain Marvel Jr.
10)Mr. Zsasz
11)Dr. Polaris
12)Katana

Oversize 1)Elasti-Girl
Oversize 2)Shazam with chair on Rock of Eternity base
Oversize 3)BA Elongated Man
Oversize 4)Johnny Thunder / Thunderbolt 2-pack

That was tough! And my list doesn't even include the Silver Age Teen Titans, Doom Patrol and Metal Men, Secret Six, New Gods, or some of the other great picks on other people's lists!

I want him Lobo sized. I saw a custom of him that used Despero and it was pretty much perfect.

See, now I gotta say this is a bone of contention for me because both Bane and Croc are human, and should come under 7 foot tall. The CnC Bane, while a great sculpt is just too tall for the character and I fear this same mistake will happen with Croc if people keep wanting him as an oversized figure. Just look back through the comics, and aside from the odd modern interpretation (I'm looking at you Jim Lee), Croc is only a bit taller than Batman. The DCSH Darksied, Mongul, DCUC Ares and Etrigan are all about the right height for Croc, taller than a regular figure, but not a giant.

I like the Arkham Asylum portrayal of him the most I think. Maybe not that big, but the overall design. Not too crocy, but still not just a scaly human. Honestly, if they could just make the DCSH one bigger and add in articulation I'd say that would be pretty much perfect. I LOVE that sculpt

I agree about the DCSH Croc, if they make that same figure about as big as Ares or Etrigan with new articulation, that would be all we need. It is a great sculpt and I think it fits nicely on the fence for those that like him as just a scaly human, and those that want him a bit more monster like but not full blown Lizard rip off.

1)Hourman (Rick Tyler)
2)Lightining (Jennifer Pierce)
3)Sand (sanderson Hawkins)
4)Dr Mid-nite (Pieter Cross)
5)Cyclone (Maxine Hunkel) with her "winged" monkey
6)Liberty Belle (Jesse Chambers)
7)Green lantern (Alan Scott) in Kingdom Come armor
Red Robin
9)Judo Master II
10)Damage
11)Modern JSA Hawkman
12)Wildcat III

Oversize 1)Jakeen Thunder with Thunderbolt
Oversize 2)Gog
Oversize 3)Ma Hunkel with JSA table
Oversize 4)Elasti-girl (Rita Farr)

Although I think we should focus on rounding out the remaining characters for 2012 first.



I'd tried to avoid using characters I put in my "rest of the initial subscription" list.

1.) Huntress
2.) Wally West/accurate height Kid Flash
3.) Changeling
4.) Brother Blood
5.) Vermin Vunderbarr
6.) Silver Swan
7.) Zauriel
8.) Tim Drake Robin in the accurate costume and accurate height
9.)Circe
10.) Vandal Savage
11.) Ice
12.) Fire

Oversize

1.) Oracle in wheelchair
2.) Granny Goodness
3.) Wildebeast
4.) Rocket Red

I never get tired of wish lists.
I know some guys hate it but I think it's harmless fun.
And I actually sometimes get excited about other people's wish lists when they remind me of characters I never thought of wishing for.

Now, I love DC villains. Can't get enough of them. Heck I keep hoping for a Royal Flush Gang or Extremists 5-pack. Maybe even a Fatal Five four pack (four because we've GOT Validus)...

But here are my priority villains

1) Weather Wizard (recent)
2) Mirror Master (classic)
3) Trickster (classic)
4) Heatwave (recent)
5) Pied Piper (recent)
6) Dr. Alchemy (recent)
7) Dr. Polaris (recent)
8 ) Evilstar (classic)
9) Goldface (classic)
10) Major Disaster (classic)
11) Cluemaster (classic)
12) Psycho Pirate, (classic)

Oversize 1) Big Sir (classic)
Oversize 2) Doomsday
Oversize 3) Mr. Atom (old school)
Oversize 4) Starro

Man, there were so many I wanted to add in but they missed the cut: Lemme just write em down for my own satisfaction- The Top, Clock King, Multi-man, Slipknot, Killer Frost, Multiplex, Atomic Skull, Vandal Savage, Felix Faust, Blockbuster, Enchantress, Shadow Thief, Chronos, Ocean Master, Dr. Light, Degaton, Rainbow Raider, Dr. Sivana, Johnny Sorrow, Jason Woodrue and Shrapnel!

I don't want to clutter the thread with discussion, but why is Granny being listed as an oversized figure? She should make it as a regular fig, right? Sure, she would require new tooling, but if you list her as oversized, you're saying that she's a $30 fig, as opposed to a $15 fig.

True.

Pack in Lashina and Stompa (and maybe even throw in Oberon), then it'd be worth the oversized price

Yeah, that's the thing about Granny.... IF they ever make her, it's like starting a new team. We'll then be campaigning to get all her Furies, and it seems unlikely Mattel would ever produce all of them. Getting just one or two wouldn't satisfy the team completists.

On a similar note to the criticism above about Granny being classified as a large scale figure -- should we be doing the same with Oracle in wheelchair? I hate having to spend $30 for a small female figure just because it'll come with a wheelchair accessory. The wheelchair wouldnt be that big, and could be disassembled in the package with simple re-assembly once we open it. I don't think any "large scale" figure should be anything less than the 8-9 inch massive characters we've become used to as C&Cs. We wouldn't feel like we're getting our money's worth. However, I have no problem with Metron since his chair is significantly bigger than a typical wheelchair accessory, and more like a massive throne.

Well, I can cross Jay Garrick, Atrocitus, and Poison Ivy off my list, since they've already been confirmed. Ignoring the rumors for now, I know who I would like to see added to this line. In no particular order:

Larfleeze
Saint Walker
Jade
Huntress
Captain Marvel Jr.
Geo-Force
Miss Martian
Element Lad
Sun Boy
Polar Boy
Mirror Master
Weather Wizard

(Flash's Rogue's Gallery is HORRIBLY underrepresented)

Large-size figures:

King Shark
Rocket Red (I voted for him as well as for Metron)

And here's an idea if Mattel does Rocket Red. Borrow an idea from Hasbro when they issued the Arctic HISS Tank in G.I. Joe and included a sticker sheet that allowed the buyer to apply whatever number combination to the side they chose. Provide a vinyl sticker sheet of numbers for Rocket Red so that we can number them as we please (and buy more than one...!)

1.) Elongated Man
2.) Zauriel
3.) Fire
4.) Ice
5.) Platinum
6.) Tin
7.) Lead
8.) Ra's al Ghul
9.) Vixen
10.) Granny Goodness
11.) Vandal Savage
12.) Killer Frost

Oversized:
1.) Doomsday
2.) Elasti-Girl
3.) Blockbuster (classic)
4.) Rocket Red

From what I've read about tooling costs over the years, it's very possible that Oracle and Metron's chairs could cost as much (or more) to make than most new characters that have new tooling costs. That's why it makes sense for those to be deluxe/oversized if the chairs are well done and new sculpts.